Kamehameha Files Request For Court To Reconsider Ruling
Court Should Decide By Sept. 13 Whether Larger Group Will Hear Case
POSTED: 5:03 pm HST August 23, 2005
UPDATED: 5:35 pm HST August 23, 2005
HONOLULU -- Kamehameha Schools filed its request for reconsideration to a federal appeals court to protect its Hawaiians-first admissions policy.A three-judge panel of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals declared the admissions policy illegal last month.In an 18-page petition, Kamehameha Schools' lawyers asked for a larger panel of judges to hear its case. It is harshly critical of the two judges who declared the admission policy illegal.The filing points out that the ruling was the first time in history that a private program to help a minority group was overturned because of a law meant to protect minorities, KITV 4 News reported."I think that's just a perversion of our justice system," Attorney General Mark Bennett said."This is a unique case of immense important to us here in the islands and the court should get it right," constitutional attorney John Van Dyke said.Much of the argument focuses on what Congress wants because Kamehameha's policies were declared invalid based on an old civil rights law. However, Kamehameha Schools points out newer laws."It is doing so because of the special political relationship between the United States and the Native Hawaiian people and the panel I think just simply got that wrong," Bennett said.The 2002 law also said the political status of Native Hawaiians is comparable to that of Native Americans."We have a bunch of very specific statutes saying that the Native Hawaiians are entitled to separate and preferential treatment," Van Dyke said.Opponents say the appeals court got it right the first time. They say that Kamehameha Schools doesn't have the legal right to exclude every non-Hawaiian applicant.The court should decide by Sept. 13 whether it will assign an 11-judge panel to hear the case. If it doesn't, then Kamehameha may be forced to admit the non-Hawaiian student who brought the case while it goes to the Supreme Court.
Previous Stories:
- August 12, 2005: Court Grants Kamehameha Schools More Time To File Appeal
- August 11, 2005: Court Refuses To Hurry Appeals Process For Kamehameha Applicant
- August 9, 2005: Court Asked To Put Student In Kamehameha Schools Immediately
- August 8, 2005: Court Denies Non-Hawaiian Boy's Request To Attend Kamehameha
- August 7, 2005: Thousands March To Support Kamehameha Schools' Policy
- August 3, 2005: Law Expert Says Akaka Bill Critical To Kamehameha Case
- August 3, 2005: Kamehameha Asks Court To Reconsider Admissions Ruling
- August 3, 2005: Court Rules Against Kamehameha Admission Policy
- November 4, 2004: Kamehameha Schools Defends Admissions Policy In Court
- November 29, 2003: Settlement Reached In Kamehameha Schools Case
- November 26, 2003: Admission Lawsuit Nears Settlement
- November 19, 2003: Judge Holds Off On Kamehameha Decision
- November 18, 2003: Judge Upholds Kamehameha Schools' Policy
Copyright 2005 by TheHawaiiChannel.com All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.






