Study Shows Rail To Increase By $180 Million
Research Predicts Increase In Ridership To 23 Percent
POSTED: 3:33 pm HST October 30, 2008
UPDATED: 9:36 am HST October 31, 2008
HONOLULU -- The city's draft environmental impact statement for its rail transit project released on Thursday said the cost of building a line from Kapolei to Ala Moana via Salt Lake would be $3.9 billion -- about $200 million more than preliminary estimates.If you adjust the cost for inflation, the cost would be nearly $5 billion."It really is an alarm bell. We just can't afford this system. This is final proof," Stop Rail Now co-founder Dennis Callan said.The report claimed rail transit would reduce traffic congestion by about 22 percent to 24 percent on Oahu. It is a figure that University of Hawaii engineering professor and former mayoral candidate Panos Prevedouros said is overly optimistic."No city has ever experienced anything over 10 percent reduction in traffic thanks to a rail system," Prevedouros said.The city says it would cost $63 million a year to operate a rail line that went through Salt Lake, but as much as $96 million a year if the line went through both Salt Lake and by the airport.The draft EIS said anywhere from 186 to 212 properties would have to be condemned to make way for the transit project, but most of them would lose only a part of their property. There would be 35 properties fully condemned and purchased by the city. That means home and business owners would be paid for their lots.Hannemann's election opponent said the city has improperly delayed releasing this report until days before the election in which transit is on the ballot."Why are we seeing bits and pieces? I think the public deserves to see the draft EIS. We paid for it. It's public money. It's a public document. We should have gotten it yesterday," mayoral candidate Ann Kobayashi said. "I just don't know what the delay is, and it's not fair to the taxpayers and residents of our city."Yoshioka said federal transit officials approved release of the report Wednesday and in less than 24 hours."We have already put out the executive summary of the draft EIS today and we're going to get an online version of the document by this weekend. We think that's pretty good time," he said.
Previous Stories:
- October 21, 2008: Hannemann, Kobayashi Tout Transit Plans At Forum
- September 23, 2008: Judges Plan To Rule On Rail Ballot Soon
- August 22, 2008: Hannemann Says No Veto For Transit Amendment
- August 20, 2008: November Ballot To Include Transit Amendments
- August 14, 2008: Judge Orders City To Put Rail Transit Issue On Ballot
- July 18, 2008: Djou Introduces Transit Charter Amendment
- July 13, 2008: Rail Issue Meets Roadblocks
- July 3, 2008: Pro-Rail Group Wants Names Removed From Petition
- June 15, 2008: Opponents Clash Over Proposed Rail Line
- June 12, 2008: Rail Opponents Take Petition To Newspaper
- May 23, 2008: City Adds Airport Stop To Transit Project
- May 7, 2008: Council Reconsidering Transit Technology
- April 21, 2008: Group Fights Oahu Mass Transit Project
- April 18, 2008: Mayor On Oahu Transit: It's Steel Or Nothing
- April 17, 2008: Honolulu City Council Derails Transit Vote
- March 26, 2008: Mayor Says Additional Taxes Must Go To Transit
- March 25, 2008: UH Study Finds Cheaper, More Effective Traffic Solutions
- March 19, 2008: Council To Vote On Transit Technology
- March 10, 2008: Public Meetings To Promote Oahu Transit Project
- February 28, 2008: Council Members Raise Concerns About Rail Transit Choice
- February 22, 2008: Transit Panel Recommends Rail For Oahu
Copyright 2009 by KITV.com All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.






